Every Pink Floyd Album, Ranked From Worst to Best
Dark Side Of The Moon may be one of the biggest-selling albums of all time, but Pink Floyd's musical journey from underground clubs to sold-out stadiums wasn't entirely smooth...
It’s difficult to overstate the influence of Pink Floyd as a defining force in rock culture. And it’s not ￼just about the number of records they’ve sold. You can reel off pages of statistics concerned with the success of Dark Side Of The Moon, but that doesn’t tell you why that album – both the music and the album sleeve itself – from 1973 became an icon for a generation. Or why Pink Floyd became a phenomenon that has affected every generation since. The answer is that they have made some of the most amazing, most singular music in rock.
The punks may have hated the band and what they often (wrongly) perceived they stood for, but Pink Floyd’s bile against the system was often as venomous as anything the punks could spit out. And through the 80s and 90s, angst-ridden teenagers, including legions who later would also make an impact with their own music – from Axl Rose to Trent Reznor to Billy Corgan to Noel Gallagher – grew up listening to The Wall. Pink Floyd had an impact on them all.
18. Soundtrack from the film More (Columbia/EMI, 1969)
It took a while to dawn on Pink Floyd that they were a great soundtrack band for their own increasingly spectacular light show. But their first foray into writing a film soundtrack is the aural equivalent of watching paint dry. It’s a disjointed series of mood pieces that may or may not have matched the scenes on screen. It’s hard to know because the film, a bunch of nonsense about hippies in Ibiza, has wisely disappeared. If you’re desperate for crumbs then check out The Nile Song, Green Is The Colour and Cymbaline, songs that cropped up in their equally disjoined stage shows at the time.
17. Ummagumma (Harvest/EMI 1969)
Released during their period of transition after David Gilmour replaced Syd Barrett, this live/studio double album did the band few favours. With no group material prepared, each member got half a side of the studio album to do their own thing. And what they proved conclusively was that Pink Floyd was considerably more than the sum of its parts. Only Roger Waters came up with a song worthy of the name, the wistful, acoustic Grantchester Meadows.
EMI were so unimpressed they hurriedly added a live album, but even onstage the band were floundering for a direction. They raked over the psychedelic ashes but the trip was audibly over apart from Careful With That Axe Eugene which created its own suspense. They get the notes right but the spirit wrong.
16. Obscured By Clouds (Harvest/EMI, 1972)
Another soundtrack to another movie about another bunch of hippies, this time looking for a lost tribe in the remote Andes (which is probably where the film, titled La Vallee, has been buried). But the difference here is that you can see glimpses of how Dark Side Of The Moon would pan out.
Floyd had already started work on their magnum opus before decamping to the Chateau d’Herouville (shortly to be renamed the Honky Chateau by Elton John) for an intense week of putting music to rushes of the movie. The results are largely lightweight but Waters brings a more thematic approach to the album and Gilmour gets to hone what would become his trademark soloing style. There are also moments of deja-vu, not least on the title track which was shamelessly ripped off by a Denim aftershave advert in the late 80s.
15. Is There Anybody Out There – The Wall Live 1980-81 (EMI, 2000)
The Wall was performed just 29 times in Los Angles, New York, London and Dortmund. It remains legendary for its extraordinary visual impact and the music had to fit the technical requirements of the show as tightly as any soundtrack the band had worked on. Not surprisingly The Wall Live sticks closely to the original album. There was, famously. a second “doppelganger” Pink Floyd that, apart from confusing the audience, filled out the sound. And there were a couple of additional numbers: What Shall We Do Now? which helped to clarify the plot a little and the instrumental The Last Few Bricks which gave the roadies more time to finish building the wall. Neither of them add anything to the original.
There only other differences are occasional variations in Waters’ vocal phrasing or Gilmour’s solos and only Floyd fanatics looking for these changes need this album.
14. A Momentary Lapse Of Reason (EMI, 1987)
Cruelly dubbed a “facsimile Floyd” album by the Roger Waters camp, David Gilmour struggled to come up with the first Pink Floyd album without Waters, even with producer Bob Ezrin and various songwriters and lyricists helping out. With Nick Mason and Rick Wright barely participating you could argue that it was a Gilmour solo album except that it certainly didn’t sound like one. More charitably you can call it Gilmour’s vision of a Pink Floyd album with his voice and guitar providing an instant familiarity. The opening Signs Of Life evokes the same atmosphere as the start of Dark Side Of The Moon, Dogs Of War would fit on the Animals album, One Slip could find a place on The Wall while A New Machine refers back to Welcome To The Machine.
13. The Final Cut (EMI, 1983)
A Roger Waters solo album in all but name, The Final Cut is a disappointing Pink Floyd album but a good start to Waters’ solo career. Wright was no longer in the band while Gilmour and Mason were restricted to doing as they were told. The overall theme – the futility of war – was never going to be a barrel of laughs but without the other members distinctive sense of drama the atmosphere of unremitting gloom becomes overwhelming.
However The Final Cut has a greater sense of clarity than The Wall. It is also more bitter and vicious as the opening Post War Dream shows with its caustic attack on the nature of war. On The Fletcher Memorial Home Waters literally spits out his condemnation of the world’s “incurable tyrants”: Leonid Brezhnev, Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher.
12. Delicate Sound Of Thunder (EMI, 1988)
In September 1987 Pink Floyd headed out on their first tour in a decade. What was planned as a short series of North American shows expanded into 200 shows around the world spread over three years.
The 2-CD live album recorded at New York’s Nassau Coliseum, opens with Shine On You Crazy Diamond with the rest of the first CD taken up by tracks from A Momentary Lapse Of Reason that stick pretty close to the originals. The second CD is a greatest hits package, starting with One Of These Days and then focussing on Dark Side Of The Moon and The Wall. Gilmour seemed happy to give individual band members their own space and while there were complaints about the reggae rhythms on Money, Gilmour’s coruscating solo on Comfortably Numb brought the show to an awesome climax.
11. Atom Heart Mother (EMI, 1970)
The first serious stirrings of ambition from Pink Floyd since Syd Barrett’s departure, Atom Heart Mother is dominated by the 23-minute title track that features an orchestra and choir. Such classical rock fusions had already been tried by Deep Purple, the Nice and the Moody Blues with varying degrees of success Pink Floyd avoided the potential pitfalls by keeping the arrangements simple. That the piece has not worn well over time is down to technical problems in the studio.
The opening brass bombast gives way to a series of mood changes that includes a celestial choir and, unusually for Pink Floyd, a funky section called Funky Dung. A pity the ending is rather inconclusive. Among the individual songs on the second side, Waters’ If stands out as a contemplative piece on alienation, a topic he would return to more forcefully later.
10. The Endless River (EMI, 2014)
Two decades after The Division Bell album and tour effectively laid Pink Floyd to rest comes this unexpected coda. It’s drawn from the jams between Wright, Gilmour and Mason as they geared up for The Division Bell but also serves as a stroll past familiar Pink Floyd musical landmarks.
It’s What We Do could be another part of Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Skins recreates the tumbling rhythms from A Saucerful Of Secrets and there’s even a snippet of Wright at the Royal Albert Hall organ twiddling with his theme to “Summer 68” (from Atom Heart Mother).
Gilmour has clearly been influenced by his dalliance with The Orb on 2010’s Metallic Sphere. Not that The Endless River is an attempt to woo the ambient crowd; it’s more of a treat for the loyal Pink Floyd fan to bask in the reverie one more time.
9. Pulse (EMI, 1995)
In the wake of The Division Bell Pink Floyd geared up for another, final, world tour but this time they planned ahead, especially when it came to staging and sound. They also took the decision to play Dark Side Of The Moon in its entirety.
Having released a live album from their previous tour they had not intended to record this one but the quality of the show proved irresistible. So another 2-CD package was born, again opening with Shine On You Crazy Diamond followed by tracks from The Division Bell and A Momentary Lapse Of Reason. It’s the second CD that hits the spot with the complete Dark Side Of The Moon and Wish You Were Here featuring the audience on lead vocals.
Some fans complained that the band stuck too closely to the originals. But not hi-fi buffs. If you want the stunning visual effects, get the DVD.
8. A Saucerful Of Secrets (Harvest/EMI, 1968)
With Syd Barrett gone Pink Floyd were now forced to rely on their nascent songwriting. Even Barrett’s final bequest, Jug Band Blues, is dark and damaged compared with his earlier freewheeling gaiety. In their grim determination to continue, Waters’ and Wright’s songs were often weighed down by a plodding dirge-like demeanour while Gilmour was solely focussed on finding his place and sound within the band.
What saves the album is Waters’ brooding Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun and the 12-minute group-written title track that begins with some tentative scraping and scratching building up to a rhythmic cacophony that eventually gives way to a sonorous organ theme. It’s a template the band would return to on later albums with increasing finesse.
7. The Division Bell (EMI, 1994)
A creditable fist of a Pink Floyd album without Roger Waters, The David Gilmour Pink Floyd, not surprisingly, wishes it was back on the moon and the album has a studied elegance as the band rekindles the flame. There’s an easy familiarity running through the tracks as the band’s trademarks are deftly reworked with the benefit of better technology.
And after suffering from a momentary lapse of lyrics, there’s some meaningful words floating around again, notably on What Do You Want From Me, Poles Apart, Wearing The Inside Out and Lost For Words, some of which may be directed against Waters. This is pristine Pink Floyd for the 90s – which may or may not be what you want from them.
6. Meddle (Harvest/EMI, 1971)
The first Pink Floyd album to reveal their real potential, Meddle takes the ideas they’d been playing around with for the previous couple of years and imbues them a sense of identity and direction. It’s vividly apparent on the trippy One Of These Days where Roger Waters’ hardcore, echo-drenched bass provides the pounding bedrock for some superannuated keyboard and guitar flashbacks, plus an eerie snippet of the Dr Who theme. It’s more leisurely apparent on the 23-minute Echoes that starts with a simple “ping” and builds, via a series of fragmented ideas, to a majestic crescendo before letting you down gently with a cosy glow.
The rest of the album is filler but you scarcely notice. Meddle is the sound of a band distilling its psychedelic past into a scintillating future.
5. Animals (Harvest/EMI, 1977)
As stripped back and direct as Pink Floyd ever got, perhaps because Pink Floyd was now controlled by Roger Waters with David Gilmour as his musical foil. Animals shuns the widescreen musical soundscapes of their last two blockbusters and instead updates George Orwell’s Animal Farm for a bleak, withering look at humanity.
Roger Waters’ lyrical vitriol drips all over the greedy, conniving Dogs, the autocratic, self-righteous Pigs (Three Different Ones) and the downtrodden but finally rebellious Sheep. These three epic tracks are book-ended by the disarming two-part acoustic love song Pigs On The Wing. The prevailing musical atmosphere is sparse and brooding with an occasional menacing edge when David Gilmour’s slashing guitar chords hack their way through the forbidding musical undergrowth. It’s not a pretty album but then it’s not meant to be.
4. The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn (Columbia/EMI, 1967)
The first album from Pink Floyd and a sparkling testament to the genius of Syd Barrett who wrote virtually the whole of this psychedelic masterpiece off the top of his head, so to speak.
Liberated by LSD, Barrett’s songs take flight on a magic carpet of cosmic philosophy (Astronomy Domine, Chapter 24), surreal whimsy (Matilda Mother, Flaming), and sublime nursery rhyme lyrics (The Gnome, Scarecrow, Bike’), bolstered by trippy, technicolour instrumentals (Interstellar Overdrive, Pow R Toc H). The rest of the band are willing and able fellow travellers.
The album was immediately pronounced sacred by the small cult of flower children and it remains the musical Mecca for British psychedelia. Sadly for Syd it was a brief flowering followed by a nervous breakdown. But his spirit has hovered over the band ever since.
3. The Wall (Harvest/EMI, 1979)
The culmination of Pink Floyd’s endeavours through the 70s, The Wall is a dense double-album diatribe on isolation, indoctrination, society and the bastards who try to control us.
From the bombastic, opening In The Flesh to the surprisingly anti-climactic Outside The Wall the plot is peppered with metaphors, flashbacks, nightmares and dreams. What saves it is the compelling musical drama that keeps you hanging in there while it all unravels.
Not that there’s an abundance of musical highlights; The Wall engrosses you, it doesn’t titillate. But they’re memorable when they do show up: Another Brick In The Wall Part 2 condenses Roger Waters’ pessimism into one greatest hit, Hey You is an eloquent plea from the other side of the wall, and Comfortably Numb is awesome in its power and simplicity.
2. Wish You Were Here (Harvest/EMI, 1975)
Following Dark Side Of The Moon’ was a daunting prospect but Wish You Were Here rises to the challenge. What it lacks in dynamics it makes up for with a controlled tension, evident from the taut opening keyboards and guitar that stretches to breaking point before Gilmour’s four-note riff brings exquisite relief.
The 26-minute Shine On You Crazy Diamond opens and closes the album. A eulogy to the pervading ghost of Syd Barrett, celebrating the genius that deteriorated into madness, it’s arguably the finest piece they wrote without him.
In between, the acerbic Welcome To The Machine and the cynical Have A Cigar (sung by Roy Harper) rage against the system, while the acoustic melancholy of the title track offers a stark contrast. The album may not have the pizzazz of DSOTM but it cuts deeper.
1. Dark Side Of The Moon (Harvest/EMI, 1973)
One of the most consummate rock albums ever recorded, Dark Side Of The Moon was an ambitious, groundbreaking concept that has become a timeless classic. It’s themed around the pressures of modern life and the insanity that can provoke, and the dynamic sound reinforces the songs’ contrasting images, from the paranoia of On The Run to the seductive requiem that is The Great Gig In The Sky.
The impact is heightened by linking sound effects, often integrated into the songs - the heartbeat at the start of Speak To Me, the cacophony of clocks at the beginning of Time and the coin-dropping speaker-hopping till-ringing jangle that opens Money. It’s a carefully measured album that took a lot of conscious effort to make but the result possesses a vitality that still has the power to thrill.